Up Close and Personal with the Amish on New York’s Amish Trail

An Amish Buggy, Cattaraugus County, N.Y.
An Amish Buggy, Cattaraugus County, N.Y.
An Amish Buggy, Cattaraugus County, N.Y.

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links to support this blog, my special-needs dog, and my traveling habit. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Somehow I mustered up the courage to speak to the man of mystery behind the counter. A thin, dark beard lined his jawbone from one ear to the other. The rest of his face was clean-shaven. I’m always tongue-tied around people like him. No, not celebrities, but members of the Amish.

My fascination with the Amish probably began before I was 5 years old. My family took road trips to visit friends in Titusville, located in Western Pennsylvania. The only two tourist activities in the area seemed to be Drake Well and driving country roads to see the Amish. They were either working on their farms or driving horse-drawn buggies.

Watch for Horse-Drawn Buggies Along the Amish Trail
Watch for Horse-Drawn Buggies Along the Amish Trail

No Photos, Please.

Some things I was told about the Amish include they don’t like having recognizable photographs taken, they can’t drive motorized vehicles, they don’t use zippers in their clothing, and they don’t have electricity in their homes. As time passed and I moved to Florida, I still had a curiosity for the Amish which was intensified several years ago after reading The Year of Living Biblically by A.J. Jacobs, in which he spent some rare, one-on-one time with an Amish family. (By the way, I strongly recommend the book, especially if you have a curiosity about the Bible’s Old Testament.)

There’s probably more I need to know about the Amish so please forgive my ignorance.

Gentner Commission Market, Springville, N.Y., Aug. 13, 2014
Gentner Commission Market, Springville, N.Y., Aug. 13, 2014

To Market, To Market…

During my summer trip to Buffalo my parents and I set out on our next adventure, the Gentner Commission Market and Springville Auction in Springville, N.Y. It’s located about a 45-minute drive south of Buffalo. Why?

In addition to it being a popular place to buy other people’s trash, it’s where some Amish go to buy goods. During a typical auction day, held each Wednesday, stuff is auctioned all morning. Meanwhile, vendors set up to sell their wares, trash/treasures, fresh produce and baked goods.

Duke's Donuts, Gentner Commission Market, Springville, N.Y., Aug. 13, 2014
Duke’s Donuts, Gentner Commission Market, Springville, N.Y., Aug. 13, 2014

I enjoyed an apple cider donut from Duke’s Donuts. They’re light yet slightly greasy, have a nice apple flavor and a little crunch from the sugar granules. At the market, pick up some homemade baked goods, such as a whoopie pie, from the Amish stand. An animal auction is in the afternoon.

Signs at the Gentner Commission Market, Springville, N.Y., Aug. 13, 2014
Signs at the Gentner Commission Market, Springville, N.Y., Aug. 13, 2014

It rained during our trip to the auction. It put a damper on attendance and the auction was shorter than a typical day. I spotted a few Amish buying produce, picking up odds and ends at the auction, and purchasing items from other vendors. I watched a young couple as they loaded a van with a full-length mirror and other wares.

“I’m going to be disappointed if he hops in the driver seat and drives away,” I told my mom.

Despite seeing Amish, I didn’t see any black buggies or horses. Did they drive to the auction? I know they can have drivers and maybe this was the case. But, I had to turn away when the bearded man with a black hat, blue shirt and black pants got into the van. I didn’t want to taint my perception of them.

Conewango is on New York's Amish Trail
Conewango is on New York’s Amish Trail

Yes, New York Has an Amish Trail

Rain cut our day short and thanks to the TripAdvisor app, I discovered New York’s Amish Trail with some of the trail located in Cattaraugus County. The website instructed us to pick up a trail map at a participating business. Although I really wanted us to head to the American Museum of Cutlery, my parents pulled into the Cattaraugus County building. I walked through a metal detector to pick up an Amish Trail map.

I’ll spare the details of our detours, but we finally found our way. We did what the map recommended, ventured down the side roads to enjoy the journey. Three stops we made were in the Conewango Valley and our first stop was an Amish shop specializing in lawn furniture.

A House Along New York's Amish Trail
A House Along New York’s Amish Trail

Standing on the front porch of a white house were three little boys with one holding a baby. The boys, all in bare feet, wore crisp, sky-blue shirts, black slacks with suspenders, wide-brimmed straw hats and rocked longer versions of Prince Valiant-style haircuts. Their cheeks rounded when they smiled and their big, round, brown eyes glistened with a mix of apprehension and curiosity when we, the “English” (non-Amish people), said “hello.”

Fish Heads on an Amish Barn on New York's Amish Trail
Fish Heads on an Amish Barn on New York’s Amish Trail

Plastic Furniture and Produce Delivery. Is This the New Amish?

We entered the red barn where I was expecting to see Amish men hard at work, cutting, sanding and bolting together wood furniture. Instead, I saw a room full of poly furniture and poly parts.

In other words, plastic furniture. The pieces arrived pre-cut and basically the Amish bolted the things together. Every piece of furniture in that room was made of plastic. The benches. The birdhouses. The picnic tables. Everything. Anyone who knows how to follow the instructions of “place A into slot B” could put this stuff together (which means every adult who’s stayed up late on Christmas Eve). Maybe the original designs are Amish but I’m guessing for half the price, I could find the same pieces at Wal-Mart.

My perception of the Amish had changed and continued to change.

Next to the cash register sat bags of chocolate covered cookies and baskets of peaches. A “fresh peaches” sign was staked in the front lawn. Now, seeing this, wouldn’t you assume these peaches were picked off an Amish orchard? Nope. The woman of the house, whom I purchased a potholder from, told us they were just delivered by the semi-truck parked out front. Plus, the peaches wore those little annoying labels, the ones that line the edge of my kitchen sink.


Was anything about the Amish what I expected? I mean, how did they place their orders for these items? Was it all by phone? (In which I believe they can use.) Or did trucks just stop by every week or so and ask what they need?

Inside an Amish Toy Shop on New York's Amish Trail
Inside an Amish Toy Shop on New York’s Amish Trail

The Amish Know Marketing

A few young boys and girls stood on the front porch of the two-story, white house at our next stop. They disappeared when we drove up their dirt driveway and parked in front of the red barn. Inside the barn was a toy shop with shelves and shelves of blonde-colored toys and other gadgets crafted from wood. Two teenage Amish boys were inside, playing with games and adjusting tools.

I’m an introvert and speaking to strangers makes me nervous, yet I force myself to do it because it’s how I make a living. I’m constantly out of my comfort zone and remind myself if I don’t speak, I miss an opportunity not only for bragging rights but life in general.

Inside an Amish Toy Shop on New York's Amish Trail
Inside an Amish Toy Shop on New York’s Amish Trail

Although I wanted to ask the bearded man behind the counter if there really is an Amish mafia, I kept it cool with the typical ice-breaking questions. To my surprise, he was quite chatty. Turns out, the shop is his father’s who had the afternoon off, so he watched the shop. Most everything is crafted either by his father or brothers. He ran the iron shop next door.

I should have picked up on this sooner and tip my hat to the Amish for doing it well. I learned on this journey that many are excellent marketers and I bought into it hook, line and sinker. While he chatted me up, he encouraged me to play a couple of games he had on the counter and I ended up buying one. Well, I was low on cash so my dad bought me one. I didn’t realize this until after the fact, but I’m guessing I could have negotiated the price. Plus, a tour guide we met on the way out asked if they gave us a good deal on the toys. Um, deal?

Toy Shop on New York's Amish Trail
Toy Shop on New York’s Amish Trail

I was fine overpaying. After making conversation and purchasing the silly little game, it opened the door for me to ask to take photos inside the shop.

“You can take photos of anything in here, just not of us,” he said.

It makes sense the Amish who interact and sell to the English are marketers because they need to make a living. I didn’t spend $10 on a silly box game because I have plans to wow my friends, I paid it because of the experience that man gave me.

He answered my questions, was personable and was engaging. Who wouldn’t want to buy something from him?

Amish Boys Drive a Horse-Drawn Buggy Along New York's Amish Trail
Amish Boys Drive a Horse-Drawn Buggy Along New York’s Amish Trail

You Butter Stop

Our final stop was at a little white shed advertising sweet butter. The woman must have spotted us through the front window of her home because she rushed out and entered through the back of the shed. She wore a navy-blue dress with a white apron, white bonnet, black stockings and black shoes. We learned the butter came from the milk of their two cows. For $2.50 we left with a pound of farm-fresh butter and an experience couldn’t get at a grocery store.

We continued on our way over the hills admiring blooms of white, yellow and purple as well as beautiful farms. Later that day I posted a photo of an Amish buggy on my Facebook page asking friends where they thought I had been. Interestingly, most thought I was in Pennsylvania. Nope. New York has a rich Amish trail making it worth the trip.

Horses Along New York's Amish Trail
Horses Along New York’s Amish Trail

If You Go

It’s pretty easy to follow the map through New York’s Amish country. Businesses are listed along the way (such as an alpaca farm). Although specific addresses for the Amish businesses aren’t listed, the map guides you in the general location. Hand-painted signs direct you where to go. Tour guides are available to guide you along the Amish Trail and the fee is $40 for a two-hour tour (at the time of this post). Geocaches are along the trail for geocaching enthusiasts. Visit www.amishtrail.com for additional information including how to book a guide.



Jennifer A. Huber is an award-winning travel and outdoor blogger and writer in Southwest Florida. Originally from Buffalo, N.Y., a hiking trail led her to a career path in the tourism industry for more than 30 years. She spent a decade with a park management company in Yellowstone, Death Valley, and Everglades National Parks. She founded the travel blog, SoloTravelGirl.com with the goal of inspiring others to travel alone, not lonely. The unexpected death of her former husband in 2008 reminded her how short life is. His passing was a catalyst for sharing her experiences with the goal of inspiring and empowering others to travel solo. Jennifer holds a Travel Marketing Professional certification from the Southeast Tourism Society, is a certified food judge, member of the NASA Social community, and alum of the FBI Citizens Academy. When not traveling, she is either in the kitchen, practicing her photography skills, or road tripping with her dog, Radcliff.

2 thoughts on “Up Close and Personal with the Amish on New York’s Amish Trail

  1. Amazing that after all that time in central PA and around upstate NY, I never toured around the Amish towns. Scenery in those parts is nice while driving through at least.

Comments are closed.

Photograph by Outdoor Afro from Nature Swagger by Rue Mapp, published by Chronicle Books.
Adventure Featured Inspiration Nature Travel

New Outdoor Book “Nature Swagger” Celebrates Black Joy

“Nature Swagger: Stories and Visions of Black Joy in the Outdoors.” is a book by Outdoor Afro CEO and Founder Rue Mapp.

Continue Reading
Cocktail expert Diana Pittet leading a Context Conversation via a Zoom call.
Cool Stuff Others are Doing Culinary Travel Featured

James Bond Got it Wrong. Martinis Should be Stirred, Not Shaken and Other Fun Info I Learned During a Context Conversation.

Join a Context Conversation to travel the world from the comfort of home. I recently tuned into a cocktail seminar, and it was a fascinating hour full of compelling history and beverage-making tips.

Continue Reading
Experience Punta Gorda Combo Special Pass - Peace River Botanical & Sculpture Gardens, Peace River Wildlife Center, Military Heritage Museum - now through Sept. 30, 2022.
Budget Travel Featured Florida Fun

Experience Punta Gorda, Florida, with Special Combo Offer through Sept. 30, 2022

New special combo pass called “Experience Punta Gorda,” is $25 and grants one-time admission to the Peace River Botanical & Sculpture Gardens, Peace River Wildlife Center and Military Heritage Museum between now and Sept. 30, 2022.

Continue Reading